Skip to main content

PeakMetrics / Fact Checks

Has this been
fact-checked?

Paste a claim or upload an image to find existing fact checks. See what fact-checkers found and read the evidence before you share.

Search fact checks ↓API & integrations ↗

Browse by topic

Explore fact checks by subject.

Latest fact checks

98,230 published reviews
BR24 FaktenfuchsClimate & environment

"Nach den Aussagen des Bundesklimaministers Herrn Habeck auf offizielle Anfrage liegt Bayern bei Installierter Leistung der Erneuerbaren Energien - aller - klar auf Platz 1. Photovoltaik sind wir Superchampion, Wasserkraft einsamer Spitzenreiter, Biomasse aus Landwirtschaft beispielsweise erzeugen wir mehr Strom als ganz Hessen erneuerbaren Strom hat, (...) und Wind sind wir stärker als Baden-Württemberg."

Publisher’s rating: Die Aussagen sind teilweise verkürzt bis irreführend, teilweise aber auch richtig.

The BR24 Faktenfuchs examined Markus Söder’s remarks in the setting of the BR24 election debate. It reports that Söder based his statement on a written inquiry by CSU Bundestag member Stefan Müller, but says the response came not from Federal Climate Minister Robert Habeck, as Söder implied, but from a state secretary at the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action. The article assesses the different parts of the statement separately rather than treating “stronger” as one consistent measure. (S1: “Er bezieht sich in seiner Aussage auf eine schriftliche Anfrage des CSU-Bundestagsabgeordneten Stefan Müller, beantwortet nicht von Bundesminister Robert Habeck (Bündnis90/ Die Grünen), sondern von einem Staatssekretär aus dem Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Klimaschutz (BMWK).”) On installed renewable capacity in absolute figures, Bavaria was first among the states, and it also led in absolute installed photovoltaic capacity. But the article cautions that these totals do not alone show how advanced expansion is: compared by area or electricity consumption, Bavaria was closer to the middle of the rankings. For photovoltaic additions in the first half of 2023, it was mid-ranking per unit of area and second per capita. The article also notes that equal installed capacity does not mean equal annual generation: photovoltaic systems have about half as many full-load hours as wind turbines. (S1: “Bayern liegt zwar nach aktuellem Stand beim Zubau der Installierten Leistung bei Erneuerbaren Energien in absoluten Zahlen tatsächlich auf Platz 1 aller Bundesländer”; “Dann rangiert der Freistaat im Bundesvergleich eher im Mittelfeld.”; “Auf die Fläche gerechnet belegt Bayern beim Netto-Zubau von Photovoltaik im ersten Halbjahr 2023 jedoch einen Mittelfeldplatz”; “Nach Einwohnern gerechnet, liegt Bayern auf Platz zwei.”; “Deshalb ist bei gleicher installierter Leistung die jährliche Stromerzeugung aus Photovoltaikanlagen nur halb so hoch wie aus Windenergieanlagen.”) The article supports the hydropower and biomass comparisons, but gives a different picture for wind. Using the latest available hydropower figures, for 2021, it reports 11.4 TWh for Bavaria and 4.5 TWh for Baden-Württemberg. It reports that Bavaria generated 9.2 TWh from biomass in 2021, against 8.2 TWh of total renewable electricity generation in Hesse. For wind, it says Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg were jointly at the bottom for onshore wind expansion; Bavaria had four permits and eleven newly operating turbines in 2023 up to the article’s reporting. (S1: “Strom aus Wasserkraft erzeugte Bayern im Jahr 2021 (aus diesem Jahr stammen die aktuellsten verfügbaren Zahlen) rund 11,4 TWh”; “In Baden-Württemberg waren es 4,5 TWh.”; “Hessen 8,2 Tera-Wattstunden Strom aus erneuerbaren Energien. Bayern erzeugte aus Biomasse allein jedoch mehr als 9 Tera-Wattstunden.”; “2023 wurden bislang vier Anlagen genehmigt, neu in Betrieb genommen wurden elf”)

FACTLYEconomy & business

After the G20 summit, Fareed Zakaria made comments on the Indian economy on his show

Publisher’s rating: MISLEADING

The claim concerns a video of Fareed Zakaria discussing India’s economy that was shared as though he had made the comments on his CNN show after the G20 summit. The review finds that the video’s analysis predated the summit: it says the analysis “was released in April 2023 after Zakaria visited India.” The summit, by contrast, took place in September 2023; the review states that it was held on 9–10 September. To trace the clip, the review says it identified the “Fareed Zakaria GPS” CNN show branding on the video, then searched online and found the same report on Zakaria’s Facebook page, where it had been uploaded on 1 May 2023. It also reports finding the video on CNN’s website and an opinion piece presenting the same analysis in The Washington Post, published on 18 April 2023. These dates place the material months before the summit, rather than after it. The review describes the segment as Zakaria’s analysis of three revolutions that, in his view, helped fuel India’s economic surge, and says he had visited India in April 2023. It concludes that the video was an earlier analysis recirculated with a false post-summit framing—not commentary prompted by the September G20 summit.

FACTLYElections & voting

A recent video of Narendra Modi making ‘vote for India’ slogans and expressing his support for the opposition’s I.N.D.I.A alliance

Publisher’s rating: MISLEADING

The claim concerns a video in which Narendra Modi urges a rally crowd to chant “vote for India.” It was presented as recent footage of him supporting the opposition’s I.N.D.I.A alliance. FACTLY’s review says the clip instead comes from an older speech and that the remarks were unrelated to that alliance: “The video shared in the post shows a clipping of Narendra Modi’s old speech made during the Mahagarjana rally in Mumbai in 2013. Narendra Modi made those remarks as part of the 2014 General Election campaign.” To check the footage, the review reports using reverse image searches on screenshots from the circulating video and searches for relevant keywords. It says these led to a video with similar visuals published by Aaj Tak on 22 December 2013, titled “ ‘Vote for India’ is the slogan for 2014 elections: Modi.” The review also points to a NewX video from December 2013 and a full speech from the rally. Its description of the original footage places the rally in Mumbai and dates it to 22 December 2013: “The full speech of Narendra Modi during the Mahagarjana rally on 22 December 2013 can be seen here.” The review distinguishes those campaign remarks from Modi’s later comments about the opposition alliance. It says he attacked the newly formed bloc, including by suggesting it be renamed “Ghamandiya.” The evidence presented therefore supports the conclusion that the clip was old campaign footage, not recent footage of Modi backing I.N.D.I.A.

FACTLYDisasters & emergencies

Videos showing the recent devastating floods in Libya

Publisher’s rating: FALSE

The review investigates social-media videos presented as recent footage of the devastating floods in Libya following Storm Daniel. It says the videos it examined were either CGI or unrelated older visuals, and focuses on two examples: one purportedly showing floodwaters submerging a bridge and another said to show a tornado sweeping through streets during a rainstorm in Libya. Its conclusion applies to these videos, not necessarily to every video circulating about the floods. (S1: “multiple videos are being shared on social media claiming that they show the recent visuals of devastating floods in Libya”; “All these videos show either CGI videos or unrelated old visuals related to devastating floods caused in different countries.”) For the bridge video, the review describes reverse-image searches of screenshots. It reports finding matching visuals posted in 2016 and identified in those posts as flooding in Al Farshah village, in Saudi Arabia’s Aseer province. The review also found an extended version on Daralakhbar.com’s Facebook page, dated 09 April 2016, which described a torrent blocking roads in Al-Farshah village in the Tihama Qahtan area of Saudi Arabia. (S1: “videos showing the same visuals were found posted by several social media users in 2016”; “This news channel reported it is the visuals of a massive torrent blocking the roads in Al-Farshah village in Tihama Qahtan area of Saudi Arabia.”) For the second video, the review says reverse-image searching found similar visuals on Shutterstock, where the video was titled “Hurricane Damage in Coastal Town.” It reports that the Shutterstock video does not show a tornado, and that the YouTube channel @rtsarovvideo described itself as creating edited videos about severe weather and natural disasters. Together, these findings point to older Saudi flood footage and edited or miscaptioned material—not the claimed Libyan flood scenes—as the sources of the two examples examined. (S1: “The original video does not show the visuals of a tornado.”; “This YouTube channel published many similar videos of tornadoes sweeping the streets.”)

BR24 FaktenfucsCrime & justice

"Das Argument, es würde zu keiner Kriminalität führen, kann man in Holland sehen, wie absurd das ist. Denn in Holland war die weitgehende Freigabe bislang. Dort finden Morde auf der Straße statt von Drogenbanden. Die Tochter des Königshauses wird bedroht von solchen Drogenbanden."

Publisher’s rating: Diese Aussage ist verkürzt. In den Niederlanden gibt es Drogenbanden, die schwerste Straftaten begehen und offenbar auch die Kronprinzessin entführen wollten. Diese sind aber laut der NGO "The Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime" hauptsächlich im Bereich von synthetischen Drogen und Heroin tätig. Die Organisierte Kriminalität habe sich in den Niederlanden aber aufgrund der Drogenpolitik ausbreiten können, sagte ein Experte.

dpa

Deze video toont een haai aan het strand van Hoek van Holland op 9 september 2023.

Publisher’s rating: De hamerhaai in de video joeg op een rog aan de kust van Orange Beach in Alabama, in augustus 2022. Er raakte niemand gewond en er is geen enkele connectie met Hoek van Holland.

The claim attaches the video to a shark sighting at Hoek van Holland on 9 September 2023. The investigation says the footage was not recorded there or that month: it traces the video to Orange Beach, Alabama, in August 2022, where it showed a hammerhead hunting a ray near the shore. The review therefore addresses the same video and alleged location, rather than a separate shark sighting. [S1: “De video leidt immers naar verschillende nieuwsartikelen in Belgische en Nederlandse kranten als Het Nieuwsblad en AD, maar ook verschillende lokale media in de VS. Daar werden de beelden in augustus vorig jaar gefilmd.”] The review describes its check as a reverse image search. It says that tracing the video led to Dutch, Belgian and US news coverage, and identifies the specific filming location as Orange Beach in the southern state of Alabama. It also identifies Catarena Peek, who filmed the hammerhead hunting rays near the beach and posted the video to her Facebook profile, where she uses the name Rena Nicole. [S1: “Een reverse image search brengt direct duidelijkheid over de herkomst van de video.”] [S1: “Specifieker was dat in de zuidelijke staat Alabama, op Orange Beach. Catarena Peek filmde daar hoe een hamerhaai vastberaden aan het jagen was op roggen vlak bij het strand en postte de video op haar Facebookprofiel (waar ze zich Rena Nicole noemt).”] The review’s account distinguishes the footage’s actual provenance from the later claim about Hoek van Holland: it says the video went viral and was subsequently picked up by media, while explicitly finding no connection to the Dutch beach. The excerpt does not provide a precise day in August 2022, so it supports the month and year, not a more exact filming date. [S1: “Het ging al snel viraal en werd dan opgepikt door verschillende media.”] [S1: “De hamerhaai in de video joeg op een rog aan de kust van Orange Beach in Alabama, in augustus 2022.”]

Where the data comes from

Fact checks come from Data Commons and link to the organizations that published them.

What you’ll find

Each result links to the original fact check. Open it to read the publisher’s findings, with summaries and supporting sources where available.

Report an error

To report an error, send the page URL and supporting evidence.