Skip to main content

PeakMetrics / Fact Checks

Has this been
fact-checked?

Paste a claim or upload an image to find existing fact checks. See what fact-checkers found and read the evidence before you share.

Search fact checks ↓API & integrations ↗

Browse by topic

Explore fact checks by subject.

Latest fact checks

98,223 published reviews
FACTLY

Visuals of mob vandalizing Karnataka buses in Tamil Nadu during Kaveri water dispute protests in 2023

Publisher’s rating: FALSE

The claim concerns a video presented as showing Karnataka buses being vandalized in Tamil Nadu during the 2023 Kaveri water-dispute protests. The review identifies the footage as showing an earlier incident: activists vandalized Karnataka vehicles in Rameswaram, Tamil Nadu, in September 2016, during protests over the same dispute. Thus, the footage does not establish that the vandalism occurred during the 2023 protests. To investigate, the review says it searched using keyframes from the circulating video and found a similar video uploaded by Nakkheeran TV. It reports comparing the visuals and finding that the circulating version was mirrored from that earlier video. The identified upload’s title also describes an attack on Karnataka buses in connection with the Cauvery dispute, supporting the review’s identification of the footage as the 2016 incident rather than a new 2023 event. The review distinguishes that historical footage from events during the 2023 protests. It says reports at the time described vehicles being stopped, but that no violence or vandalism had been reported so far. The material therefore supports the conclusion that an old video was recirculated with a misleading claim about when the vandalism occurred.

dpaHealth & medicine

ideo zeigt echte Aussagen von Christian Drosten: "Masken bringen nichts, lassen Sie diesen Lappen im Gesicht weg."

Publisher’s rating: Das Video wurde manipuliert: Drosten werden darin erfundene Worte in den Mund gelegt. Als Grundlage diente ein Mitschnitt einer Bundespressekonferenz aus dem Jahr 2020. Der Clip ist offenbar satirisch gemeint.

The claim concerns a TikTok video that appears to show virologist Christian Drosten saying, “Masken bringen nichts, lassen Sie diesen Lappen im Gesicht weg.” The dpa investigation examined that specific clip, in which the words are presented as Drosten’s speech and accompanied by dramatic music. It reports that the video’s lip movements do not match the alleged words, an indication that the speech was manipulated rather than genuine. [S1: “Auf der Videoplattform Tiktok ist ein Video aufgetaucht: Es zeigt den Berliner Virologen Christian Drosten, der sich angeblich über Menschen aufregt, die noch immer Schutzmasken tragen. «Masken bringen nichts, lassen Sie diesen Lappen im Gesicht weg», sagt der Wissenschaftler unter anderem angeblich in dem Clip. Mit dramatischer Musik werden die Aussagen untermalt.”; “Die Lippenbewegungen von Christian Drosten passen nicht zu den angeblich gesprochenen Worten.”] To investigate the footage’s origin, the review reports using a reverse image search. A suggested YouTube result showed a 15-minute compilation of Drosten’s remarks at a Berlin federal press conference on 9 March 2020. The camera angle matched the TikTok clip, and the same man crossed the frame in both videos. The review says this footage was the likely source of the TikTok clip. [S1: “Eine Bilderrückwärtssuche liefert zudem den Hinweis, dass das Bildmaterial im Zuge einer Bundespressekonferenz (BPK) im Jahr 2020 entstanden ist.”; “In dem Video läuft bei Sekunde 25 derselbe Mann durch das Bild, der auch in dem Tiktok-Clip bei Sekunde 4 zu sehen ist. Die Einstellung der Kamera-Perspektive stimmt ebenfalls überein. Das Youtube-Video zeigt also dasselbe Bildmaterial wie der Tiktok-Clip und diente wohl als Grundlage.”] The alleged sentence does not appear in that compilation. At the moment the man crosses the frame, Drosten is discussing the limited new findings about the then-novel coronavirus; the review also reports that he did not say masks “nichts bringen” elsewhere in that speech. It cites a Phoenix recording of the entire 9 March press conference as evidence. Thus, the clip uses real event footage, but the review finds that the quoted words were not actually spoken in the source recording. [S1: “Doch in dem Youtube-Beitrag fällt der vermeintlich gesprochene Satz «Masken bringen nichts, lassen Sie diesen Lappen im Gesicht weg» nicht. Im Gegenteil: Als der Mann durch das Bild läuft, erklärt Christian Drosten gerade, dass es nur wenige neue Erkenntnisse über das seinerzeit neuartige Coronavirus gibt. Von Masken ist an der entsprechenden Stelle keine Rede.”; “Das belegt eine vom Fernsehsender Phoenix veröffentlichte Aufzeichnung der gesamten Bundespressekonferenz vom 9. März 2020.”]

Bei den Waldbränden in Kanada im Sommer 2023 haben keine Bäume, sondern nur Häuser gebrannt.

Publisher’s rating: Hier fehlt wichtiger Kontext: Die Aufnahme zeigt verbrannte Häuser, die bei einem Waldbrand nahe der kanadischen Stadt West Kelowna zerstört wurden. Andere Videos und Fotos belegen jedoch: Das Feuer hat auch Bäume vernichtet. Dass Bäume mitunter einen Waldbrand überstehen können, ist nicht ungewöhnlich und hängt von verschiedenen Faktoren ab.

The claim was attached to a video showing houses burning near West Kelowna, British Columbia, during the McDougall Creek Wildfire. The review says the footage does show houses destroyed in that fire, but it does not establish that trees were untouched across the fire area. The fire began on August 15, 2023, and covered 139 square kilometres. The review’s central distinction is between what is visible in this particular clip and what happened in the wider wildfire.

dpaClimate & environment

Bill Gates a une autre "excellente" idée : abattre des milliers d’hectares d’arbres pour contribuer à réduire les émissions de CO₂. Les arbres absorbent en fait du CO₂ et libèrent de l’oxygène !

Publisher’s rating: Bill Gates n'a pas l'intention de déboiser 70 millions d'acres (demi-hectares) de forêt à travers l'une de ses sociétés. Le co-fondateur de Microsoft finance en réalité le développement d'une technologie d'éclaircie forestière et de séquestration du carbone. Cette solution implique l'enfouissement dans le sol d'arbres considérés comme à risque d'incendie afin de garder sous terre le CO2 qu'ils ont absorbé tout au long de leur vie.

The posts at issue said that a company financed by Bill Gates intended to cut down 70 million acres of trees to reduce CO₂ emissions. The review identifies Kodama Systems as the company behind the project and says Gates’s Breakthrough Energy Ventures fund and other investors provided it with more than $6 million in December 2022. Kodama’s stated aim was to develop technology for selective forest thinning and carbon storage, not to clear all the trees across 70 million acres. The proposed approach is to bury dead or fire-risk trees removed during thinning, rather than leave them to burn or decompose and release their carbon. The review explains that thinning is intended to remove selected trees and brush to reduce fire risk and help healthier trees thrive. It also notes that the U.S. Forest Service’s plan covers increased management of 50 million additional acres at high fire risk; the separate 70-million-acre figure was reportedly a broader forest-thinning target that was misread as an area to be completely cleared. The review reports that Kodama spokesperson James Sedlak called the claim false in an email to dpa on September 29, 2023, and said the 70-million-acre figure had been misinterpreted. The underlying carbon-storage proposal was still a developing technology: the review says its effectiveness, costs, environmental impacts, and ability to keep carbon stored over time remained to be demonstrated.

Gezondheid en wetenschapHealth & medicine

‘In een recente wetenschappelijke publicatie, in samenwerking met de universiteit van Parijs, bleek hormoonbehandeling in de (peri)menopauze effectief in de strijd tegen dementie bij vrouwen. Toch dringt die optimistische boodschap in Vlaanderen nauwelijks door en neemt angst vaak de overhand’

Publisher’s rating: Eerder onwaar

The statement under review, attributed in the article to Flemish politician Gwendolyn Rutten, presents a recent study as showing that hormone treatment during peri- or menopause is effective against dementia in women. The review says the study was narrower: it involved menopausal women who carried APO E4, a gene associated with greater Alzheimer’s risk, and compared women given hormone therapy for six months with a similar group who did not receive it. The measured outcome was a blood biomarker linked to Alzheimer’s risk, not the occurrence of dementia. The review reports that the biomarker concentration was lower in the treated group after six months. That result does not establish that the treatment prevents Alzheimer’s or dementia. As the review explains, the researchers inferred reduced risk from a change in the biomarker, but the study did not show that APO E4 carriers actually developed Alzheimer’s less often. The review also notes that the value of these blood biomarkers for estimating Alzheimer’s risk was disputed, and cites a European-American task force calling for their refinement and saying they were not then sensitive enough to identify people genuinely at risk. The review adds that prior research did not consistently support a protective effect: it points to a large controlled study of women aged 65 and older in which women receiving hormone therapy developed dementia more often, not less. Taken together, the reported findings support a limited observation about a biomarker in a specific group—not the broader claim that hormone treatment is effective against dementia in women. The review therefore treats the optimistic interpretation as unproven.

dpaHealth & medicine

Video zeigt Fake-Impfungen u.a. bei Londons Bürgermeister Sadiq Khan.

Publisher’s rating: Dafür gibt es keine Belege. Das Foto von Londons Bürgermeister Sadiq Khan etwa entstand dessen Büro zufolge kurz vor der eigentlichen Impfung. Das kurze Zurückziehen des Spritzenstempels wie im Video von Markus Söder ist eine übliche Praxis bei Impfungen. Bei den beiden anderen Politikerinnen zeigen weitere Aufnahmen, dass sie tatsächlich geimpft wurden.

dpaHealth & medicine

Le ministre français de la Santé signale qu'ils vont rembourser les préservatifs pour les enfants de moins de 6 ans.

Publisher’s rating: Non, il s'agit d'un lapsus du ministre de la Santé, Aurélien Rousseau, pour lequel il a présenté des excuses. Les préservatifs sont remboursés pour les jeunes de moins de 26 ans (et non les moins de six ans), a-t-il corrigé. Ceci est également écrit noir sur blanc dans le Projet de loi de financement de la sécurité sociale 2024, dont il présentait les grandes lignes au moment de son lapsus.

dpaEconomy & business

Dies ist ein Gewinnspiel von Ebikes.

Publisher’s rating: Das angebliche Gewinnspiel ist nicht seriös.

The claim concerns a Facebook post presenting a giveaway of 480 bicycles supposedly unsellable because of “minor scratches and damage.” The post said users could enter by commenting “Danke” and might then be selected at random to receive a bicycle. The dpa review examined the linked participation and registration pages, rather than treating the post’s description as proof that bicycles were actually being given away. The review reports that the participation link led to a page whose address began with sites.google.com, not the name of a company or shop. Although a photograph showed the e-bike.de shop address in the background, that address did not appear in the linked page’s URL. The page also lacked an imprint and directed clicks to the same link. A later page requested personal information and named a UK company as responsible, without mentioning e-bike.de. The review also notes that a bicycle image came from a different, genuine shop giveaway, and that the Facebook page posing as Ebike lacked a verification badge and had no other posts. Taken together, those findings do not substantiate the advertised giveaway: the links and page details instead failed to connect the offer to the shop whose name and imagery it invoked.

Where the data comes from

Fact checks come from Data Commons and link to the organizations that published them.

What you’ll find

Each result links to the original fact check. Open it to read the publisher’s findings, with summaries and supporting sources where available.

Report an error

To report an error, send the page URL and supporting evidence.